Top 5 Tips For Managers New To The Hiring Process

September 8, 2022

Interviewing and the interview process, from the initial screen to the last sit-down with the hiring manager, can be the make-or-break a moment in the candidate’s experience.

All your preparation and work up to this point could be for nothing if the interview doesn’t go well.

The following are simple tips to improve interview skills and techniques, as well as the candidate’s experience.


BE PREPARED

Prep on the candidate’s background and have questions ready to go when interviewing. Help prepare candidates for interviews with hiring managers. Not being prepared for an interview is a disservice to the candidate and the whole process. Too many recruiters are skimming the resume while walking into the interview. Research the candidates and write out questions in advance. Provide the candidate with as much information as possible [about the job] to determine if this really is the right match for them. I can’t stress enough how important it is to understand the employer and really sell what it does—the job, benefits, and projects.

BUILD RAPPORT

Establish trust and a genuine connection to build the foundation of a good relationship. Strong rapport is the foundation of that relationship. If you haven’t built rapport in the beginning, and you don’t feel like you’re able to connect conversationally, it doesn’t give a good vibe for the energy of the company or yourself and does not reflect well on what the candidate’s experience will be like going forward.

BE RESPECTFUL

Give candidates your undivided attention, put them at ease, and be transparent about the process. This is a candidate’s market. You can bet that if you’re late for an interview, they will go and report that on Glassdoor or Indeed. Don’t throw curveballs to try to trick candidates or glean insight into their personalities with off-topic questions. The basic social etiquette must be practiced—sit up, show interest, make eye contact, and turn off your phone.

COMMUNICATE WELL AND OFTEN

The first touch point, the screening interview, should always be with the recruiter. Some hiring managers want to skip this step and go directly into their own interviews to save time, but this formative time spent with the recruiter is key. Be responsive and maintain a high level of communication with your candidates. Make sure the recruiter is very responsive and keeps you in the loop every step of the way.

REVIEW YOUR WORK

Subject your interview process to continuous self-improvement. You never want to become stagnant, and we are surely not interviewing the same way today as we did years ago. Ask your peers to shadow the calls and hear your questions to see if you’re missing anything or to see how you can change up your technique. Then return the favor and shadow them.

Sometimes, interviewers are more stressed out than interviewees, especially when they’re unprepared. These tips will get you ready and help you represent your company in the best way possible while finding the best possible candidates.

We have recruiters that will learn about your workplace and culture, use our resources to find candidates, vet out the top contenders for your company, screen and interview, and send you the best candidate. Our team continually delivers the right employees.

Complimentary Talent Review

Our firm is committed to providing personalized staffing solutions that meet your unique business needs. With our extensive network and expertise in recruiting, we ensure that your organization gains a competitive edge by hiring the best in the field.

Hiring Insights Start Here


Vanessa McClure-Leach

An adaptable, knowledge-driven professional, I bring a creative, problem-solving mindset and a genuine passion for building strong relationships. I specialize in executive and leadership hiring across industries such as aerospace, manufacturing, and non-profits, as well as recruitment for HR, Accounting/Finance, Administration, and a variety of other roles. My approach is centered on listening and learning- gathering comprehensive insights from both clients and candidates to ensure the best possible match. I take pride in creating outcomes that lead to mutual success and long-term happiness for everyone involved. Beyond my professional expertise, I am passionate about humankind, equality, the environment, and animal welfare. Guided by kindness and a commitment to making a positive difference, I strive to use my voice to advocate for others and contribute to a better, more compassionate world.

We’re Social!

0 Comments

Accounting & Finance Job Titles to Watch in 2026

Accounting & Finance Job Titles to Watch in 2026

Finance teams are changing fast. This guide spotlights 2026 titles that reflect real work: AI enabled FP&A Strategist, Finance Data Product Manager, Autonomous Close Controller, Treasury Liquidity and Funding Strategist, Sustainability Accounting Lead, Pricing Partner, Digital Asset Policy Lead, and an M&A Value Creation Architect. Use it to sharpen scopes, refresh descriptions, and plan training.

Hiring Without Burnout: How to Support Your Internal Teams During High Growth

Hiring Without Burnout: How to Support Your Internal Teams During High Growth

High growth should not mean late nights and frayed quality. This guide shows how to plan capacity, make load visible, run a sane interview cadence, and centralize candidate communication. You will also learn how to blend internal stretch with smart external support, track early signs of overload, and build a ready bench with an onboarding ramp so new hires contribute quickly without burning out the team.